Shapiro Esrogim › Guides
How to Choose an Esrog: What to Look For
Most people choose an esrog once a year, standing at a crowded table with a magnifying glass they are not sure how to use. This is what is actually worth looking at, in plain words.
First, know what your Rav and your minhag say
Families and communities differ on which kind of esrog they use and on what they are particular about. If you have a minhag, start there. If you have a Rav you show your esrog to, ask him once what he looks for. It makes every year after that easier.
The top third matters most
The upper part of the esrog, from where it starts to slope in toward the top, is called the chotem. A mark there is taken far more seriously than the same mark lower down. So look at the top first, at arm's length, the way you would normally hold it. What counts is mainly what the eye sees without hunting for it.
Clean does not mean perfect
An esrog grows on a thorny tree, in wind, among leaves. Almost every esrog carries something.
- Bletlach are light tan, flat scars left where a leaf or a thorn rubbed the fruit as it grew. They are part of the peel and are normally not a problem. Many very fine esrogim have them.
- Dark dots, spots of a different colour, and blisters are what people look out for, above all on the chotem.
- Missing peel or a hole is a serious question. Show it to a Rav.
Whole, top and bottom
- The oketz is the short stem at the bottom, where the esrog hung from the tree. It should be in place, sitting in its hollow.
- The pitam is the small woody tip at the top. If an esrog grew with a pitam, the pitam should be whole. Many esrogim grow without one, or lose it early on the tree. Those are kosher, and plenty of people prefer them because there is nothing to break.
Shape
A nice esrog is wider at the bottom and narrows toward the top, like a tower. The top sits more or less straight above the stem. The skin is bumpy and ridged, not smooth like a lemon.
Colour and size
An esrog should be yellow, or clearly turning yellow. One that is still green usually yellows over the days before Yom Tov. For size, it has to be larger than an egg, and many are careful to take one comfortably bigger. It should sit well in your hand.
The one thing you cannot see
An esrog must come from a tree that was not grafted onto another citrus, such as a lemon. You cannot check this by looking at the fruit. It rests entirely on knowing the orchard and the tradition behind it. This is the real reason to buy from someone you trust. Our esrogim come mainly from Israel, and some of them are Chazon Ish esrogim.
What "kosher" and "mehudar" mean when you buy
Every esrog we sell is kosher. The levels above that are about beauty: a cleaner chotem, a finer shape, a more even colour. That is hiddur mitzvah, and it is why two kosher esrogim can have very different prices. See what each level of set means.
If you would rather not choose at all
That is what we are here for. We check every esrog by hand, one at a time, and that is how each one is priced. You choose a level, we pick the esrog we would take for ourselves at that level, and you show it to your Rav.
This is a general guide, not a halachic ruling. For any real question about your own Arba Minim, ask your Rav.
